Sacred Coercion: “Ordained by God” is Not a Constitutional Justification.
Sacred Coercion: “Ordained by God” is Not a Constitutional Justification. by Colin Smith Attorney • Politician The United States is not a confessional state. The Constitution presupposes a plural citizenry: people with different metaphysical commitments, different moral authorities, and different accounts of ultimate meaning. Within that framework, the legitimacy of government coercion depends on something basic: public justification . When a public official advocates a policy that imposes material penalties—detention, exclusion, deportation, denial of status, denial of access—the official bears a burden of justification that is not discharged by appeals to sectarian authority. This is not a demand that officials abandon religious belief. It is a constraint on the grounds upon which coercion is publicly defended in a plural polity. Recent remarks attributed to House Speaker Mike Johnson present an unusually clear test of that principle. Johnson reportedly argued that the biblica...